For best experience please turn on javascript and use a modern browser!
You are using a browser that is no longer supported by Microsoft. Please upgrade your browser. The site may not present itself correctly if you continue browsing.

ASCA Philosophy and Public Affairs Lecture Series

Event details of Matthé Scholten: Mental Disorder and Moral Responsibility: A Kantian Account
Date 29 October 2014
Time 16:00 -18:00
Location Oude Turfmarkt 145-147
Room Oude Turfmarkt 147, Faculteitskamer
ASCA

In this paper I give a Kantian answer to the question why, if at all, people suffering from mental disorders that fall within the schizophrenia spectrum should be exonerated from blame. I answer that question by reconstructing Kant¹s account of mental disorder, particularly his explanation of psychotic symptoms. I show that on Kant¹s view these symptoms are due to various cognitive impairments and discuss Kant¹s claim that the unifying feature of the disorder is the patient¹s inability to enter into a mutual exchange of epistemic or moral reasons. After developing a Kantian Quality of Will Thesis, I analyse some real life cases. I argue, firstly, that patients who are unable to enter into a mutual exchange of epistemic reasons are exempted from doxastic rather than moral responsibility. They are exonerated from blame only if their actions do not express a lack of good will. Secondly, I argue that patients who are either unable to form intentions and make plans or unable to enter into a mutual exchange of moral reasons are exempted from moral responsibility on the grounds that they do not satisfy the requirements for moral agency.

 

Oude Turfmarkt 145-147

Room Oude Turfmarkt 147, Faculteitskamer

Oude Turfmarkt 145-147
1012 GC Amsterdam