Sleep is no cure for painful memories
Should you sleep right after a stressful experience, or better not? According to sleep and memory researcher Faya Reinhold, it turns out not to be a simple yes-or-no question, as often thought. In a realistic experiment involving karaoke, to trigger feelings of embarrassment, she found no evidence that sleep helps us forget, but also no reason to believe it does any harm.

People who struggle to fall asleep are often told to change habits like drinking coffee or watching TV close to bedtime. But for many, the problem is not what they do before going to bed, but what they bring to bed: stress, fear, grief, or shame. The big question is whether sleep changes the emotional weight of these feelings. There are two opposing theories: one says that sleep preserves and strengthens the emotional charge of experiences, the other that sleep actually weakens it.
Listening to embarrassing karaoke recordings
To find out which theory holds true, Reinhold used karaoke experiments to evoke personal memories and a sense of embarrassment.
Participants sang two songs, which were recorded, and then listened back to one of them. Twelve hours later, they listened to the recordings again: one group had slept in the meantime, while the other had stayed awake during the day. Both groups also listened to their second, previously unheard recording to test whether their reactions were specific to the earlier embarrassing recording, or reflected more general emotional changes. While listening, researchers measured facial blushing as a sign of embarrassment.
Less blushing after sleeping
Participants who had slept blushed less when listening back, but this was true for both the familiar and the new recording. ‘Because the new recording might have reminded them of the original embarrassing moment, it is unclear whether this positive effect of sleep comes from changes in the memory itself or from better emotion regulation,’ Reinhold says.
Emotional memories after a week of sleep
But what if one night of sleep is not enough to fully process the emotional memory? In a follow-up study, participants listened to the first recording either around noon or in the evening right before they slept and listened to both recordings one week later. Once more, researchers measured blushing.
Again, participants blushed less when listening to both recordings but rated the experience as more negative. ‘How soon someone slept after the experience, or relived the memory, had no clear effect on how strong the emotion remained,’ Reinhold says. ‘We also found no evidence that the positive effects of sleep were specific to that memory, even after several nights of sleep.’
The quality of sleep
Finally, an experiment involving a stressful situation, such as public speaking, cautiously suggested that it wasn’t whether people slept, but how well they slept, that mattered. ‘Participants who slept better experienced fewer intrusive memories, while those with more variable sleep quality suffered more,’ Reinhold notes.

The past few years have taught me that emotions, memory, and sleep are far more complex than I ever imaginedSleep and memory researcher Faya Reinhold
A good night’s sleep may be beneficial
‘What seemed like a simple yes-or-no question – whether sleep strengthens emotional memories or not – turned out to be much more complicated,’ Reinhold concludes. ‘The past few years have taught me that emotions, memory, and sleep are far more complex than I ever imagined, let alone the combination of all three.’
Still, the research yielded valuable insights: ‘Sleep doesn’t appear to be harmful after a stressful event, as one theory suggests. In fact, our findings cautiously indicate that a good night’s sleep may be beneficial after a distressing experience. But sleep is not necessarily a reliable “natural therapeutic tool” either.’
PhD thesis and defence
These experiments were part of Reinhold’s PhD study: Golden Slumber? The Elusive Role of Sleep in Emotional Memory. (Supervisor: Prof. dr. M. Kindt, Co-supervisors: Prof. dr. E.J.W. van Someren and Dr. R.M. Visser).
She will defend her PhD thesis on Monday, 10 November, 16:00–17:30, at the Agnietenkapel in Amsterdam