Tabitha Oost is an assistant professor of Constitutional and Administrative Law at the University of Amsterdam. Her research asks what the law can achieve when confronted with historical or grave injustices — and what happens when recognition of that injustice is organised outside the law. In her doctoral thesis on the restitution of Nazi-looted art she maps a paradigm shift: from a legalistic approach to one centred on the perspective of victims and their heirs. Comparative research into practice in the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Austria and Germany shows that this shift leaves restitution committees vulnerable for as long as it remains unanchored in legislation.
That finding informs two adjacent lines of research. In her Dutch-language work she examines how concepts such as recognition, legal redress and compensation relate to one another where the state acts voluntarily in response to large-scale suffering. Her work also addresses the restitution of colonial cultural objects, where the same tension between moral recognition and legal foundation is at play, and where the agency of source communities raises questions of its own. In 2019 she was awarded the inaugural Lalive Merryman Fellowship in Art and Cultural Heritage Law for her mapping of the paradigm shift in Nazi-Looted art restitution cases.